CheapWineRatings.com

Good Value Makes Wine Taste Better
Michelle said on March 24th, 2009

I met winemaker Scott McWilliam back in September, when he was touring the US to promote his wines. I got to spend a fair amount of time with him since I was writing a print article (why that’s more important than a blog, I’ll never know). I was surprised to find out that they’re one of Australia’s largest wineries, with vineyards all over the gigantic SE Aus appellation. They sell mostly entry-level wines in the States, but he apparently makes a killer line of sherries. Unfortunately, we have to head down under to get them. I’ve always been pretty impresssed with his lines available here – esp for the price.
Oh, and he’s this young (maybe 35, tops) blonde guy. He looks like he’d be more at home with a surfboard than a vineyard. I was happy to spend some time with him. ;-)

Mark said on May 14th, 2009

Tim,
I agree with your overall accessment of the McWilliam’s Shiraz but only 86 pts? Seems a tad low. This is a pretty decent inexpensive Aussie Shiraz in my opinion. However, I also paid less than 10 bucks for it in my neck of the woods…which may be swaying me towards being a little too complimentary about it.

Tim said on May 14th, 2009

Hey Mark, thanks for your comment. Yes, ONLY an 86. I don’t see 86 as a bad score. If it is, then the critics of the 100 point system are right.

It was a couple months ago since I tasted this wine and I don’t recall exactly why the numbers broke out the way they did, but I follow a consistent process in evaluating each wine. According to my notes the wine didn’t lose points in any one specific category but a point here or there for the areas in which it could have been better. It could have had improvements in viscosity, intensity, concentration and acidity. There are some areas where it was very good, just not stellar and in this case that broke out to an 86. It’s a good wine.

GiveItAbreak said on April 16th, 2010

Oh please can we ever stop these ridicuous pretentious wine scores and review/tasting notes….86 jammy, spicey, blah blah blah give it a break already.

Tim said on April 16th, 2010

No, sir. We cannot stop.

Track & Pingback
Trackback and pingback from other bloggers
April 23rd, 2009 at 8:10 pm McWilliam's Hanwood Estate Merlot mention something about this post....

Leave A Comment

 Username

 Email Address

 Website